Tested security keys
Which keys KeyMelier was tested with by hand, on which system, and what worked. 13 of 27 combinations have a result; Not tested means nobody has reported it yet – it does not mean it fails. Every FIDO2 key should be detected; what a specific key can do is shown in the app under What this key can do.
Report your key (a short form, without serial numbers or account names) · How to test and the rules
| Operating system | KeyMelier | Key model | Firmware | Detection | Read functions | Cancel & reconnect | Result | Date, notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| macOS 27.2, Apple M1 | 1.8.9 source / 56147c103a5d32b77914988d60fd89494c6d6ac8 | FEITIAN K33 (owner identified), USB 096e:0866 | Not confirmed (HID version 1.0.1) | Passed (getInfo after owner replaced USB cable) | Passed (corrected empty passkey store read; PIN-assisted fingerprint list at c1a011a) | Passed (pre-cancel only); physical reconnect during an operation Not tested | Passed (listed source-probe workflows only; partial coverage) | 2026-11-15 – isolated read-only source harness, owner-entered PIN; one fingerprint listed, 0 passkeys/128 free slots, retries 8 to 8. Initial empty-store failures reproduced and corrected. Legacy local scope separation; management UV tokens Not supported. No reset, enrollment, credential or setting changes; signed package/UI acceptance remains open. |
| macOS 27.2, Apple M1 | 1.8.9 source / 56147c103a5d32b77914988d60fd89494c6d6ac8 | FEITIAN BioPassFIDO2, USB 096e:085d (casing model unconfirmed) | Not confirmed (HID version 1.0.1) | Passed (getInfo) | Passed (corrected empty passkey store read; PIN-assisted fingerprint list at c1a011a) | Passed (pre-cancel only); physical reconnect during an operation Not tested | Passed (listed source-probe workflows only; partial coverage) | 2026-11-15 – AAGUID 77010bd7; separate device from K33. Isolated read-only source harness, owner-entered PIN; one fingerprint listed, 0 passkeys/128 free slots, retries 8 to 8. Initial empty-store failures corrected. Management UV tokens Not supported. No reset, enrollment, credential or setting changes; signed package/UI acceptance remains open. |
| macOS 27.2, Apple M1 | 1.8.9-rc.2 / c42768c68bc0434ec73a290e2bcda545e3e70605 | YubiKey 5 Series with NFC (Consumer Profile) | 5.8.0 | Passed (installed app, initial connection and reconnect) | Passed (passkey list, separate settings unlock, passkeys after settings; Read key with active token and explicit unlock after expiry) | Passed (unsubmitted PIN cancellation preserves 8 retries; disconnect preserves known data; reconnect requires fresh unlock) | Passed (listed workflows only; partial coverage) | 2026-11-14 – owner enters PIN locally; app UI observed directly. Read after more than 300 seconds requires unlocking. No reset or PIN/settings/passkey change. Fingerprints Not supported on this key; in-flight unplug, waiting UV cancellation and other platforms remain untested. Earlier source-probe PIN rejections remain recorded separately above. |
| macOS 27.2 (owner-reported), Apple M1 | 1.8.8-rc.8 / 8544da222f34db55a25e34c0e497d8485bf0e683 | YubiKey (exact variant not reported) | 5.2.7 | Passed (start and detection, owner-reported) | Passed (Read key, owner-reported; individual areas not recorded) | Passed (PIN cancellation preserves retries; native reset cancellation, reconnect invalidates stale consent, fresh Read key, new consent after disarming) | Passed (listed workflows only; partial coverage) | 2026-11-06 – owner also confirmed OATH clipboard expiry after 35 seconds and preservation of different/identical text recopied in TextEdit. Correct reset target/action; offered Enter/Escape/close paths cancel. No actual reset performed. Other clipboard managers and public certificate copies not tested. See WINDOWS_QA_RC8.md. |
| Windows 11 Pro 10.0.26300 (x64) | 1.8.8-rc.7 / e6b4217580f72a29931ba300cce2d8578db33363 | YubiKey 5 Series with NFC | 5.2.7 | Passed (model/firmware observed) | Passed (synthetic OATH account creation and code copy, owner-reported) | Not tested | Passed (OATH rendering, clipboard and test-account deletion; partial coverage) | 2026-11-05 – literal markup/quotes in the test name; code expiry after 35 seconds, different and identical Notepad recopy preserved, subsequent public AAGUID copy preserved. Native deletion identified the test account; only that account was removed. Other PIV/OpenPGP/OTP workflows not tested. |
| Windows 11 Pro 10.0.26300 (x64) | 1.8.8-rc.7 / e6b4217580f72a29931ba300cce2d8578db33363 | TOKEN2 PIN Plus Security Key Series | 0.1.0 (same test key as RC5) | Passed (owner-reported packed attestation, all seven checks; chain valid to token2.com) | Passed (Read key with existing PIN after rejected stale consent) | Passed (reset consent Enter/Escape/close; reconnect invalidates old consent; fresh request requires new confirmation) | Passed (listed workflows only; partial coverage) | 2026-11-05 – owner supplied complete attestation output. Native reset dialog names correct action/target, cancels safely, rejects acceptance after disconnect/reconnect, and requires a new confirmation after disarming. No actual RC7 reset performed. See WINDOWS_QA_RC7.md; other application/upgrade/clipboard checks remain separate. |
| Windows 11 Pro 10.0.26300 (x64) | 1.8.8-rc.5 / 3cd4a48976518ff9c8b92f0f5ed4f3508a3ddebe | Feitian K33 (owner identification); USB BioPassFIDO2 | Not reported (CTAP raw value 0) | Passed (CTAP detection; PIN-assisted attestation Passed) | Passed (Read key with PIN, owner-reported; individual areas not recorded) | Not tested | Passed (PIN-assisted attestation and reading; partial coverage) | 2026-11-05 – native getInfo observed; owner supplied installed app result: all seven attestation checks Passed, packed format, valid chain to Feitian FIDO Root CA and certificate AAGUID matches model. Owner also confirmed Read key with PIN completes without errors. No PIN/account data recorded. Fingerprint route and cancellation/reconnect remain untested. |
| Windows 11 Pro 10.0.26300 (x64) | 1.8.8-rc.5 / 3cd4a48976518ff9c8b92f0f5ed4f3508a3ddebe | TOKEN2 PIN Plus Security Key Series | 0.1.0 | Passed (model/firmware shown); RC5 attestation Unverified | Passed (Read key on empty key, owner-reported; individual areas not recorded) | Passed (reconnect only, owner-reported); cancellation Not tested | Passed (reset, new PIN, reconnect and read only; partial coverage) | 2026-11-05 – observed installed RC5 UI; EXE hash matches published RC5. Owner reports successful reset, new PIN setup, unplug/replug and Read key with new PIN. RC5 attestation reports an unverified chain; the legacy-root false negative is corrected for RC6 and passes an offline evidence recheck. Cancellation and stale-confirmation rejection remain untested. See WINDOWS_QA_RC5.md; no full hardware sign-off. |
| macOS (version not recorded) | 1.8.6 candidate (exact commit not reported) | Two keys, models not recorded | not recorded | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Passed (general use reported; individual checks not recorded) | 2026-10-26 – project owner reports running 1.8.6 on the Mac with two connected keys: looks good. No model, firmware or per-function results supplied; not a full hardware sign-off. |
| Windows (version not recorded) | 1.5.0 | not recorded | not recorded | Passed | Not tested | Not tested | Passed (installation and start only) | 2026-09-27 – reported by the project owner: Windows build installed with the installer and working. No details about key or functions recorded. |
| macOS + Windows (versions not recorded) | 1.6.0 | – | – | – | – | – | Passed (sync between two computers) | 2026-09-27 – reported by the project owner: sync Mac ↔ Windows set up and working. Not a key test. |
| macOS (version not recorded) | development state 1.3.1 | YubiKey with FIDO 2.0 (shown as "YubiKey OTP+FIDO+CCID") | not recorded | Passed | Passkey search: Passed (70 sites asked, 4 with passkeys) | Not tested | Passed (search) | 2026-09 – diagnostic run during development (local log). App version not exactly known; a hint only. |
| macOS 14/15 | 1.7.0 or newer | YubiKey 5 (FW 5.7) | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | – |
| macOS 14/15 | 1.7.0 or newer | YubiKey 5 (FW 5.1/5.2, FIDO 2.0) | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Passkeys by search only |
| macOS 14/15 | 1.7.0 or newer | YubiKey Bio | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Check fingerprint instead of PIN |
| macOS 14/15 | 1.7.0 or newer | Token2 (PIN+ / FIDO2.1) | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | – |
| macOS 14/15 | 1.7.0 or newer | Feitian (ePass/BioPass) | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | – |
| Windows 11 | 1.7.0 or newer | YubiKey 5 (FW 5.7) | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | App starts with administrator rights |
| Windows 11 | 1.7.0 or newer | YubiKey 5 (FW 5.1/5.2, FIDO 2.0) | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | – |
| Windows 11 | 1.7.0 or newer | Token2 (PIN+ / FIDO2.1) | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | – |
| Windows 10 | 1.7.0 or newer | any FIDO2 key | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | – |
| Containers: Ubuntu 24.04/26.04, Debian 13, Fedora 43, openSUSE Leap 16.0 (x86_64 + aarch64), Arch Linux (x86_64); Xvfb, no USB | 1.8.0 candidate | – | – | – | – | – | Passed (AppImage starts, self-test 46 checks, 11 of 11 combinations) | 2026-09-27 – automated start test on native CI runners (Build run 36342999686, CI job linux-compat), without a key, USB, Wayland or a real desktop. Not a hardware result. |
| Ubuntu 24.04 (GNOME, Wayland) | 1.8.0 or newer | YubiKey 5 (FW 5.7) | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | AppImage; check access without the udev rules (systemd) |
| Ubuntu 24.04 (GNOME, Wayland) | 1.8.0 or newer | Token2 (PIN+ / FIDO2.1) | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Authenticator/OpenPGP/PIV need pcscd |
| Fedora (KDE Plasma) | 1.8.0 or newer | any FIDO2 key | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Sync with KWallet (Secret Service) |
| Debian 12 / older distribution | 1.8.0 or newer | any FIDO2 key | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Does the AppImage start at all (built on Ubuntu 24.04)? Udev rules from the AppImage |
| Raspberry Pi OS 64-bit (aarch64) | 1.8.0 or newer | any FIDO2 key | – | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | Not tested | ARM64 AppImage |
Results are only listed when their origin is known; automated tests (see TESTING.md) do not count as hardware results.